Trump’s refusal to accept election results dampens democracy, but young people’s will to preserve it is stronger
Throughout American history, only one president has openly called undocumented Mexican immigrants “rapists.” Only one president has mocked a disabled person on national television. Only one president has been both impeached and has run for re-election. Only one president has repeatedly downplayed a virus that has reached over 12 million domestic cases and a death toll of 250,000 people.
And now, only one president in American history has refused to concede presidential election results well after they were called.
That’s our current president, Donald J. Trump. For many young people like me, his refusal to accept the results has begun to dim our faith in the state of American democracy.
Since the election results were officially announced on Nov. 7, Trump has attempted to reverse what has been deemed the “most secure election in American history,” according to cybersecurity officials, and has alleged voter fraud despite multiple failed court cases and a growing void of nonexistent evidence.
Trump has refused to meet with President-elect Joe Biden for a peaceful transition of power and even met with Michigan lawmakers in an extraordinary attempt to subvert the state’s electoral votes. But unlike his grandiose claims, Trump did not win big. He lost — and by a huge margin: over six million votes. Political analysts have branded Trump’s refusal to accept his loss a subversion of democracy with dangerous implications for the president’s power.
As students, we have learned in school that democracy is the cornerstone of a free and fair society. Citizens vote in elections for officials who will represent the interests of the people and abide by ethical and legal boundaries.
Trump’s refusal to concede is a shameless violation of these boundaries. And this isn’t the first time he has broken the principles of democracy — from firing government investigators because they were investigating him to endorsing the beating and demonizing of journalists. Trump has also delegated numerous advisor and other government positions to his family members and inner circle since the beginning of his presidency. That’s plain nepotism.
Presidents should serve as a moral beacon for our society, wielding their influence to uplift, resolve and unite. Trump has twisted whatever moral fiber he has into a perverse normalization of all that is illegal, obscene and malicious. He has disrupted our perception of what a president should and should not do. Nothing can rob the trust kids and young people have for their government more than one that cheats and befouls.
There is clearly something resonant about counting the thousands dying every day from COVID-19, which has generated silence from our president. There is something resonant about the inability of working-class families to advance the socioeconomic ladder. There is something resonant about seeing the Black bodies killed on our streets by police — the 21st century’s version of the strange fruit that once hung on America’s poplar trees.
For many members of Generation Z, including myself, our cynicism and hopelessness amid great tragedies and inequalities is strong — but our desire to overcome them is even stronger.
We’ve seen young people turn to the streets in solidarity with the Black Lives Matter protests. Many have used their voices online to generate movements demanding social and economic justice, which helped fundraise over six million dollars for Breonna Taylor, an innocent Black woman killed by police earlier this year. And in this presidential election, voter turnout among millennials and Generation Z reached unprecedented levels, with a majority voting for Biden.
Young people have clearly held out their hope, and rightfully so: Biden won the election and he plans to reverse the destructive policies of the Trump administration. Biden’s victory serves as evidence that through our grassroots efforts, our democracy is worth saving.
Not all of us agree on policies or social issues, but our huge turnouts in activism, I believe, must indicate some collective desire to move forward from the woes of these past four years and have our voices heard. If you look at Trump’s presidency with nostalgia, I don’t know what to tell you. And I certainly can’t speak for you.
For most of us, however, our efforts to unseat Trump — at least from office — are largely over. New reports find that Trump, though outwardly refusing election results, is preparing for post-presidency life. I think we all know what will happen on Jan. 20 — it is now only a matter of seeing how quickly the idea of a second Trump presidency withers.
In some sense, Trump’s presidency has only ever been about fleeting ideas: about a universe where wronged whites take back their country from an influx of immigrants tainting the racial pool. About a wall south of the border to keep out imaginary criminals. About a return to traditional gender hierarchies where women remain confined to the glass ceiling. About a return to the defects of our country’s past.
These are the ideas our democracy tried to exile throughout the decades — from the 19th amendment that granted women the right to vote to the Civil Rights Act of 1964 that outlawed racial discrimination. America set a precedent to abandon the vices of the past and look to civility, equality and compassion for a better tomorrow.
For young people like me, Trump’s refusal to concede — abandoning not only the will of the American people but the legal and moral principles of the democratic tradition — must at least awaken our senses to the fragility of our democracy.
It is indeed suffocating under the boot of an administration that seems oblivious to the rule of law. But I also believe in the vision young people have forged to preserve our democracy. I believe in the struggle and spirit of working class families, including mine, who grapple with the risks of the pandemic because they believe in the promise of America. I believe in every student enduring the troubles of remote learning, which has upended education and exposed grave inequalities in America’s school system. I believe in the 80 million voters who cast their ballot this month with heart and reason in mind.
And I believe in you.
Democracy is in your hands. You have the power to shape it with every action you take. I encourage you to consider volunteering for political campaigns, whether local or national, as I have done this year. Attend peaceful protests, though safely, on the streets or online. Talk to family, friends and strangers about what you see wrong in our country. Tweet about it. Do something.
It is up to you and all of us to keep our democracy alive — and I know we will.
As a senior, I’m excited to return to the Crusader staff for the second year. I believe in journalism’s ability to highlight the key issues, trends,...
Hi! I’m a junior at BVH and this is my second year on the Crusader staff. My position this year is staff artist, which means I get to make graphics and...
Felix Navidad • Dec 8, 2020 at 10:29 pm
Good job on the story. 2020 has been a crazy year and very disappointing senior year. I respectfully offer the following thoughts to your article.
Some believe that the United States is a democracy, but it is actually a perfect example of a constitutional republic.
A pure democracy would be a form of government where the leaders elected by the people, are NOT constrained by a constitution. In other words, the largest mob rules and the losers are more than reminded about it.
Perhaps the mayors of both Seattle and Portland believe in pure democracy. I believe that the mayors took the rights away from those who lived/worked/owned businesses in the autonomous zone of CHAZ and in downtown Portland.
The mayors of both Seattle and Portland may believe they are NOT constrained by a constitution as to its actions or inactions while governing. Perhaps they believe they are the poster children of the new pure democracy.
In a republic, however, elected officials cannot take away or violate certain rights of the people.
Alexander Hamilton, himself a Federalist, stated that the government being created was a “republican government,” and that true freedom would not be found in a dictatorship nor a true democracy, but in a moderate government. I don’t believe that trump is a moderate. I don’t believe the mayors of Seattle or Portland are moderates either.
I’m tired of politics, but this is not the first nor will it be the last “running around the room, hair on fire election.” Don’t let anyone convince you otherwise. There is a good article that may provide some insight into contested presidential elections. https://www.history.com/news/most-contentious-u-s-presidential-elections.
I completely agree that it is time to stand up and peacefully protest. It is also time to have a civilized conversation to understand others viewpoints. My extended family escaped a socialist democracies. Millions have also escaped the same poverty, lawlessness, corruption, and promises of free, free, free. Those promises were never kept, nor will they ever be.
I back law and order. My relatives are police officers and I ask them lots of questions, then listen to better understand. I do believe there are a lot of areas that need addressing I’m searching for proposed solutions by the leadership of BLM and others. I have not been able to find constructive solutions or discussions. ACAB, F-12, or anarchy are not discussions or solutions. They are not peaceful slogans.
Here’s a thought! What about patient lives matter?
A recent Johns Hopkins study claims more than 250,000 people in the U.S. die every year from medical errors. This is about the same number of COVID deaths so far this year. Other reports claim the numbers to be as high as 440,000. Medical errors are the third-leading cause of death after heart disease and cancer. https://www.cnbc.com/2018/02/22/medical-errors-third-leading-cause-of-death-in-america.html
Advocates are fighting back, pushing for greater legislation for patient safety. They are not breaking windows of hospitals, clinics, or doctors’ offices. Would that be socially acceptable?
Is 250,000 people in the U.S. dying every year from medical errors not a cause worth fighting for? We have closed schools, ruined sports, proms, and all other normal activities this year based on the number of cases and deaths. This does not even begin to discuss the other issues of be isolated, confined at home, afraid to leave the house, afraid to visit with family. How many BVH students have lost parents, grandparents, uncles or aunts to COVID 19? How many did not get the opportunity to say good bye?
When do we begin peacefully protesting doctors and hospitals for the 250,000 medical error deaths per year? When do we start shaming them and the nurses who cover for the mistakes?
I completely agree, talk to family, friends and strangers about people dying alone in hospitals, people being buried without the respect of families or friends to console each other. YES we must protest what we SEE is wrong in our country. COVID is 99.3% non-lethal for most of the population.
Please take the time to read and perhaps do an article on https://www.health.harvard.edu/diseases-and-conditions/treatments-for-covid-19
Why are doctors sending people with COVID home to quarantine – take two aspirin and that’s it. Go to the hospital if you get really bad. It should be noted that the hospitals also have social distancing and are limiting capacity just like stores and restaurants. 25% -45% of what the old normal capacity was by order of the governor via the health officer.
It’s December and we know much more than we did in February. I’m sure by now they have some idea what proactive treatments have shown great results.
A quick search brought me to this https://www.americasfrontlinedoctors.com/custom_videos/the-way-forward-doctor-to-doctor/
Why has the governor limited proactive treatments being investigated that have shown really really good results such as the ones in the Harvard article?
Why are those proactive treatments only available to those already admitted to hospitals? Isn’t that a little late?
Why are only hospitals and not your family doctor or clinic allowed to prescribe COVID-19 treatments – outside the hospital?
These are some questions to Tweet about. Ask questions, listen, research, then…… Do something.
Carmel Weifert • Dec 2, 2020 at 11:24 am
I think you’ve hit the nail on the head in this piece.